Craig & Cindy’s Vacation Rentals
Key West, FL (Truman Annex, Coral Hammock & Beachside)
Hilton Head, SC (Palmetto Dunes Plantation)
Comments From Past Guests

Click here to return to Craig & Cindy's Vacation Rentals

Click here to e-mail us and ask questions or to request our free Key West brochure!

Welcome!  We are Craig & Cindy and we thank you for reviewing our websites and considering one of our properties for your next stay in Key West or Hilton Head.  We have been offering rentals since 1996 and almost exclusively by way of the world wide web.  We believe our properties are first class and, by the amount of repeat guests who stay with us year after year, we believe you will enjoy your stay with us.  To follow are a few recent comments from guests:

Note - beginning Summer 2009 we started having our guests post their comments on the Craig & Cindy Key West Rentals Facebook Page so they could post comments and pictures directly to our page.  We have received many comments and pictures and would love to share them with you.  To see this page Click Here.  Below are comments prior to summer 2009.

July 6, 2009 from Kathy - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"We had a wonderful time!  Sid and I feel we stayed in the best location in Key West.  The Truman Annex community is beautiful.  The Fleming Street house met our needs perfectly.  Our son and daughter and her boyfriend also loved it.  We were all so comfortable there.  The way you handle your rentals is very simple and extremely efficient.  Your booklet of information was very handy.  Sid had it with him everyday.  There's no doubt when we return to Key West, we will make sure that Fleming Street is available before we make our plans.  Thanks for your hospitality."

May 29, 2009 from Dan - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"The cottage was awesome!  Location is so convenient to just about everything but unbelievably quiet at night.  Very comfortably furnished and in great condition, felt at home right away.  Also your cleaning people do an excellent job.  Will definitely recommend your rentals to anyone we know.  Thanks for providing a great home base for our vacation."

May 28, 2009 from Scott & Cheryl - stayed at one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:
"Yes, we had a great time in Key West.  We all loved the house and especially having the pool right out the back door.  We will certainly look you up again in the future if we decide to go again."

May 24, 2009 from Bob & Pam - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:
"Just got home late last night from our wonderful vacation in Key West!  We just love it there!!  Truman Annex was fantastic!!!!  We were so close to everything!  Thanks again for another amazing vacation.  We met some nice people, ate some delicious food and discovered a few new favorite places!!  Thanks for all you do to make vacations a dream come true!!!  We will definitely keep you in mind for our future travels!!!!"

May 18, 2009 from Wanda & Bert - stayed at our Beachside Condo:
"We were so impressed with the condo and its furnishings.  And the marble shower and Jacuzzi - I want them for my house now, too!  Now I know just how I want to redecorate.  Loved the vacation.  Loved the condo.  If we get the chance we will pass your name along.  Thanks so much.  The washer and dryer helped loads, too."

May 10, 2009 from Anita & Matt - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:
"Just wanted to let you know we had a fantastic week, Shipyard was perfect for the 2 of us and the outdoor deck was perfect for grilling, morning coffee and reading.  The condo was in great shape, clean, and in a fantastic spot to get to Duval Street, Fort Zachary State Park, and one of my favorites...the Blue Heaven restaurant.  Thanks again and hopefully we will be back again next year!!!"

April 16, 2009 from Matt - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:
"I travel throughout the world for vacation usually out of the country 2-3x's a year.  The value you offered with the quality is tops.  I've been to Key West dozens of times.  This has been our best visit to date.  Thanks."

March 30, 2009 from Bob & Jan - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:
"We had a great time in Key West!  The condo was just right.  Close to the pool, but not too close!  The Truman Annex is a great location as we were able to walk to everything.  We will certainly keep you in mind for next year.  Thanks again for being so organized and easy to deal with."

January 7, 2009 from John - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:
"We had a wonderful time at your rental unit in the Truman Annex.  The unit was very clean and it had all the necessary amenities including the great music on your CD player.  It's location near to Duval Street and the wharf is very convenient.  We hope to rent from you again in the future."

December 19, 2009 from Hubert - stayed at our Beachside Condo:
"Wanted to drop you a line to let you know that your place at Beachside was fantastic.  We had a great time and the weather was great.  Thanks!"

December 18, 2008 from Pete - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:
"Just wanted to thank you for allowing us to rent your place in Key West.  We had a wonderful time and the house was ideal.  Cannot say any negatives about it.  Hoping to go back perhaps same time next year and, if we do, I would like to rent the house again.  Thank you again and I will recommend your places to my friends for future trips.  Have a great holiday!"

November 14, 2008 from Gene - stayed at our Beachside Condo:

"We had a great time and I can't thank you enough for letting us stay at your wonderful place.  I could go on and on about what a great place it is.  If we have any other friends heading down to Key West I will for sure recommend you guys and keep you in mind for future travels.  Thanks again!"

October 20, 2008 from Scott - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"Just arrived.  Thank you!!!  You might have to get us evicted.  You have a wonderful home here.  I can't imagine ever wanting to stay anywhere else.  Thanks again."

October 20, 2008 from Lison from Belgium - stayed at our Beachside Condo:

"We checked in yesterday evening - and we have to tell you:  your place at the beachside resort is just great!!!  Perhaps we run into one another in the next week - we'll be happy to pay for a round of drinks!  Cheers."

September 29, 2008 from Patty - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"Craig and Cindy I just wanted to let you know that we had a wonderful time in Key West.  We loved your 212 Fleming.  It made us feel like we were at home.  When we make our next trip to Key West I will definitely be in touch.  Thanks again."

August 7, 2008 from Mark & Diana - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"We loved our trip to Key West!  Thank you very much for allowing us to stay in your beautiful home!  Everything about our stay was just perfect!  It might sound corny but I was so excited to have a washer and dryer to use on a beach vacation!!  The location was great given Ft. Zachary was just a short walk away and the older girls loved the independence of being able to walk to Duval Street!  Also thanks for the guidebook of your recommendations that you provided!  We truly found it helpful in planning our dinners and activities!!  We snorkeled, parasailed, we loved the Original Ghost Tour, and the four hour private guided Kayak tour of the Mangroves proved to be the best!!  More than anything though it was wonderful to experience much needed family time in such beautiful surroundings.  We even got used to the wake up call from a rooster!  Thank you again and we hope to stay at your home again next summer!  In fact, our girls were in 100% agreement (that doesn't happen too often) that we need to come back next summer!"

July 7, 2008 from Matt & Kristen - stayed at our Beachside Condo:

"Thank you so much.  We thoroughly enjoyed our visit.  We knew the condo would be nice, but even after viewing the photos online, we were absolutely stunned upon our arrival at how nice it was.  Everyone at the resort was very helpful and we used several of your suggestions for things to do while there, so thanks!  (Blue Heaven was the best!).  This was our first visit to Key West but will definitely not be our last."

June 13, 2008 from Jennifer - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"Thanks for making our vacation in Key West a relaxing and memorable trip.  Everything was just as described and depicted on the website. I hope we will be back again soon."

June 13, 2008 from Sandra - stayed at one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Thank you so much.  We could not have been happier.  The house was gorgeous and most of our days were spent in the fabulous, clean pool.  We had the best time."

June 5, 2008 from Beth - stayed at one of our Truman Annex properties:

"We had a wonderful time.  Key West was so much fun.  This was our first trip there after having lived in Florida for the past 18 years.  The house was pefect, very clean on our arrival and very well equipped.  We had considered a hotel and are so happy that we decided to go with a home.  We will definitely recommend you to others and will rent again from you in the future."

May 26, 2008 from Bobby & Karen - stayed at our Beachside Resort Condo with their son who had just returned from Iraq:
"We want to thank you very much for the great vacation in your Beachside Condo in Key West.  The condo was perfect for us!  The memories we have there are precious!  Our son and family were impressed and thrilled with the condo and the amenities.  After being in Iraq, my son stated this was the greatest gift to relax with the family.  We are sincerely grateful for letting us be your guests in your beautiful paradise home."

May 25, 2008 from Adrian & Crystal - stayed at one or our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Hi Cindy and Craig.  We just touched down a few hours ago in New York and would just like to thank you for hosting us.  We had a great time and, even though we had been to Key West before, this was our most memorable vacation, in no small part thanks to you."

May 22, 2008 from Gord - stayed at one or our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Just a short note to tell you how much we enjoyed our stay at your rental property in Key West.  All our needs were met and then some.  Thank You!!  The parking pass came in handy, the pool was superb, the back porch was our main eating and relaxing area.  We had such an excellent vacation.  Definitely will recommend the property to others.  Thanks again!!"

May 20, 2008 from John - utilized our "Last Minute Discount" specials and stayed at one or our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"We had a great time, especially the last-minute arrangements.  The accommodations suited us perfectly and it was everything you said.  We would certainly recommend it to friends."

May 19, 2008 from James - stayed at our Beachside Resort Condo:

"We had a wonderful time and really enjoyed staying at the Beachside Resort.  We will definitely be telling our friends about it and no doubt trying to get back down there ourselves.  It was a great week and your condo was excellent, a really quality place.  Also, I would just like to add how helpful and easy it was organizing our holiday through you."

May 9, 2008 from John & Becky - stayed at one of our Fleming Street Houses:
"We had a wonderful time at 214 Fleming Street!  Great location - within walking distance to everything!  What a great way to experience Key West for the first time.  The house had everything we needed.  And was exactly like the pictures on the website.  We look forward to renting from you in the future!"

May 9, 2008 from Mike - stayed at our Beachside Resort Condo:
"Thank you so much for letting us stay at your beautiful Key West condo.  We enjoyed everything the place had to offer from the pool to the relaxing atmosphere of your condo.  We couldn't be more thrilled by how wonderful everything was.  I hope we can stay there again in the future.  Once again thank you."

February 29, 2008 from Brenda - stayed at our Beachside Resort Condo:
"Dear Cindy and Craig.  It's been wonderful.  Beachside is spectacular and most particularly your unit.  We are sad to leave but want to thank you so very much for allowing us to be your guests and to enjoy your condo here in Key West."

February 24, 2008 from Jeff & Elaine - stayed at our Coral Hammock Royal Palm House:
"What a great house!!!  It was better than we expected!  The house had everything we needed, was spotless when we arrived and was close to all of the action down on Duval Street without all of the noise and traffic that goes along with Duval Street.  We even had our own rooster to keep us company.  It was a great vacation for us and we wanted to thank you for making our stay so enjoyable.  We're already talking about a return trip and we'll definitely be staying at one of your places when we make that trip.  Thanks again!"

February 13, 2008 from Mike - stayed at our Coral Hammock Royal Palm House:
"I'm already lobbying the other 5 members of our clan for a return engagement to Key West.  We all appreciate your professional work and the ease of navigating around your house and Key West.  Everything went well and that week will be fondly remembered.  Pete and Peg chatted with us at the pool and said that you were sold out but helped them rent a neighbor's unit.  Thanks Cindy for doing such a good job."

January 10, 2008 from Bob & Pam - stayed at our Coral Hammock Royal Palm House:
"Our family had such a wonderful time at your rental (20 Coral Hammock) in Key West!!!!  The parking garage pass is such a wonderful bonus.  We went down to Duval Street every day; sometimes twice a day!!!!  Christmas day we had dinner at a fantastic Italian restaurant!!!  The sunsets were the best and I did enjoy waking up to the roosters and sitting out on the top deck with a morning cup of relaxing!!!"

December 16, 2007 from Sara - stayed at our Oceanfront home at Bay Point:
"Just wanted to write and say we are here in the house on Bay Drive at mile marker 15 and its absolutely fabulous!  I've stayed in rental houses over the years out west skiing and also at warm weather destinations a couple of times and this is by far the nicest one I've ever stayed in.  The house itself is wonderful with the granite counter tops and high end cabinets and appliances plus its very clean throughout.  Its nicely decorated and the furniture is nicer than I thought I would ever see in a vacation rental.  Since I made the reservation my husband and our 2 friends gave me credit for finding this wonderful place so I was the hero when we got here.  Thank you!"

September 27, 2007 from Don - stayed at our Oceanfront home at Bay Point:
"I wanted you to know that Dani and I really enjoyed our June vacation.  The home was immaculate and in a beautiful location.  We enjoyed being close to Key West and its attractions while still having a quiet location to return to.  Thanks again for letting us stay in your home."

September 3, 2007 from Joanne & Roy-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:
"Well, another satisfied customer here!  We all thoroughly enjoyed our stay.  It went WAY too fast!  You two certainly assured your guests of total comfort.  Thanks for all your efforts - they were so appreciated.  Thanks again for buying this property.  It's beyond our expectations!"


August 8, 2007 from Sherry-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"We had the most amazing time with our family in Key West last week!!  You have a beautiful home at Coral Hammock.  The booklet you sent was extremely helpful.  Thank you."

July 30, 2007 from Jamey-stayed in our Truman Annex Porter House:
"We really had a great time during our stay in Key West.  Your home is absolutely beautiful.  The pictures on your website do not do it justice!  The girls said their vacation in Key West was the best vacation ever.  My husband and I are already discussing the possibility of making Key West our yearly family vacation destination.  Should we decide to go back next year we will definitely be contacting you for our rental.  The location of Porter Lane was the most ideal location and again your home is just a dream!  It was 100 times better than we had expected.  Not that we had low expectations!"


July 29, 2007 from Kyle-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"I wanted to say thank you for helping make our trip so enjoyable.  The house was wonderful and as advertised.  The location was great with easy access to everything that we wanted to do.  The rooms were great and the access to the pool was fantastic.  The parking pass to the Old Town Garage really came in handy too.  Thank you for providing such a lovely home!"


June 19, 2007 from Deborah-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:
"I just wanted to drop a quick line and let you know how much we enjoyed our stay in your Coral Hammock homes.  The cleaning people were still there when we arrived and they were literally on their hands and knees cleaning the floors and bathrooms.  They do an excellent job.  The kitchen was so well stocked with everything we needed to cook with.  We got a lot of use out of the rafts for the pool and beach chairs.  Everything was well thought of!"

May 1, 2007 from Jon & Lisa-stayed in one of Truman Annex homes:

"We had the best time at your place.  Everything was better than advertised.  We will be in touch when we plan our next trip."


January 11, 2007 from Julie & Trev-stayed in one of Truman Annex homes:

"Having arrived at your house....I only wish we had arrived sooner.  It is one thing to see the pictures on your website (and it looked lovely then).  When we opened the door we didn't actually believe what we were seeing.  On every trip we have made to the USA we have stayed in hotels.  I can tell you now, we have decided that WE WILL BE BACK, and we won't be staying in hotels.  It was so nice to arrive and instantly feel like it was your home...and that is how we treated it.  You had furnished your home with everything you could possibly need in a vacation home and my daughter loved your CD player.  She spent many times just flicking through your CD's to see what you had.  You have great taste in music.  We did think that now she is 16 that, this might have been our last trip to the USA with her, but seeing your house...6 days after arriving back in the UK she said can we go back next year and stay in Craig and Cindy's house?  From a moody teenager that is praise indeed.  Plus you have the added bonus of having a house in one of the most beautiful, laid back places we have ever traveled to.  The locals are extremely friendly and welcoming and made us feel totally at ease.  Once again thank you for loaning us your Key West Paradise for our vacation."


August 28, 2006 from Rick-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Staying in and returning to the Coral Hammock location was very convenient to everything and certainly your directions and instructions were very helpful to the tee.  We had a wonderful stay at Coral Hammock - the three bedroom accommodations were perfect for the eight of us.  The accommodations were fresh, very nice and first class.  It was a good experience that I will recommend to my other family members and friends and positive we will request to use again in the future thru you."

August 21, 2006 from Lori-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"It has been 2 full weeks since we stayed at your lovely home.  I wanted to drop you a line and express to you how wonderful the accommodations were for us.  I would recommend your home to anyone going to Key West.  At no time did we feel cramped or on top of each other.  Considering there was 8 of us, and we rented site unseen, we were a little apprehensive, and then pleasantly surprised.  Key West was magical and we can't wait to come back."

August 4, 2006 from Janice-stayed in our Oceanfront Bay Point House:

"We're home in Weston but our hearts are still at Bay Point.  What a wonderful time we had!  It had all the comforts of home and more.  You have a special place there and please know you definitely have renters for July (and maybe more) next summer.  Thank you so much for sharing your relaxing and comfortable property with us."

August 1, 2006 from Barbara and Jon-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Fleming Street Houses:
"We had a wonderful time in your house.  You thought of everything!!  We have great memories and will be planning our trip for next summer.  I think we will do 2 weeks as it was too hard to leave!  I am including a picture of all of us at your wonderful home and I am sending your web page to all of our friends."

August 1, 2006 from Scott-stayed in our Truman Annex Porter Lane House:
"I cannot tell you what a wonderful house you have in Key West.  I am so envious.  The location could not have been more perfect and your home is stunning and very well appointed.  The pool was the biggest surprise.  In the photos it appears not to be much...however the functionality of the pool was great and we spent many hours just "chilling out".  Thanks again and we will see you again."

May 22, 2006 from Dale & Brenda-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:
"Just wanted to pass along we really enjoyed our visit to Key West.  Staying at your property in Coral Hammock added to the enjoyment.  It was our first trip to Key West and certainly won't be our last.  I also wanted to let you know we really appreciated the parking garage pass.  We used it on a daily basis.  We have passed your website on to our co-workers and friends and shared with them the great experience we had with renting a property through the two of you."

May 7, 2006 from Edwina-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Fleming Street Houses:

"We rented your home at 216 Fleming in April.  My son got married while we were there.  I had to drop you a note and let you know how much we enjoyed staying there.  It was absolutely perfect for us to walk just about everywhere and be away from the noise of Duval which is exactly what I was looking for.  Your website was a true indication of what to expect.  The home was nicely appointed and sparkling clean.  I hope that we will be able to return to KW and rent from you again.  If you would ever like to use my name as a referral, I would be happy to have you use my name as a reference."

April 3, 2006 from Courtnee-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Shipyard Condos:
"Hi Craig & Cindy!  We just wanted to say thanks-we had a WONDERFUL time in Key West.  The condo was so great.  We walked downtown every night.  The location was perfect.  I'm glad I found you guys and was able to book this trip.  It was very memorable."

February 22, 2006 from Clifford-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:
"I just wanted to say thank you for giving me the opportunity to stay in your rental house in Coral Hammock.  It was quite a treat as I have been staying in motels for the past trips to Key West.  You have a very nice rental home.  If I ever have another opportunity, I would love to be able to stay in your rental home again."

November 18, 2005 from Jeff & Aimie-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Fleming Street Houses:
"Hey Craig & Cindy...Just wanted to let you both know what a wonderful time we had at your 212 Fleming Street House.  We were married on October 1st 2005 at Smathers Beach.  Our honeymoon was wonderful!  Thanks to both of you for renting us the beautiful home.  It was a dream come true!  There was enough room to get ready for our wedding and have our family over before and after the ceremony for cake.  Everyone was very comfortable due to all of the space.  It is a beautiful home and we hope to have an opportunity to stay in one of your homes again in the future.  Neither of us think we could stay in a hotel again while on vacation!  It felt like being at home while on vacation.  Please keep us informed of any specials you have going on.  We're ready to go back to Key West and get away from this Chicago weather!  Thanks again for was just perfect!"

May 21, 2005 from Ken & Catherine-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Thank you for allowing us to rent your beautiful property!  Marcela (our cleaner) had it "white glove" condition and all amenities were so convenient.  We had a wonderful time and will be certain to refer you to our friends."


May 16, 2005 from Kevin-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Fleming St Houses:

"Just a quick note to say thank you for allowing us to rent 216 Fleming Street.  The house was perfect for our needs and we felt it was ideally located in Key West - close enough to shops, beaches, places of interest, Duval Street etc. but in a quiet residential area.  I will certainly recommend your properties and will contact you if and when we decide to stay in Key West again."


May 16, 2005 from Fred, Trish, Steve & Peggy-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"We all would like to thank you for the great stay we had in Key West.  The place was perfect.  The attention to detail is truly what made the stay so enjoyable.  The (CD Player) disk changer with preloaded and programmed music was a nice touch.  We had everything we needed and found the place very clean and comfortable.  Thank you."


May 8, 2005 from George & Carol-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Craig, had a great time.  You obviously know how to set up and quip a unit.  You thought of everything - lots of small touches that made a difference between an "OK" vacation and a memorable experience."


May 2, 2005 from Mike-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Fleming St Houses:

"Just wanted to drop you a line and tell you how much we enjoyed the house.  We definitely want to do that again and have already started looking at dates for next year.  Thanks again."


April 15, 2005 from Carol-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Thank you for renting your house!  We had a great time and will recommend your properties....AND WILL BE BACK!  Your entertainment center was awesome!  I never saw the need for a 300 disk CD player...until you use one!  Better yet was that we share the same musical interests...your selection of CD's was great!


March 22, 2005 from Kathy & Dan-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"Our family just returned from our vacation in Florida which included a stay at #15 Coral Hammock in Key West.  I just wanted to tell you what a spectacular place you have.  We couldn't have been happier.  The pool area is the best.  The water was very warm which made it perfect.  Having a spacious home to come back to at the end of fishing or snorkeling is the only way to vacation.  WE will definitely remember you again when planning a vacation.  Once again-thanks to your great web site we had a great vacation on Key West."


March 8, 2005 from Brian & Susan-stayed in one of our Coral Hammock Royal Palm Houses:

"We just wanted to drop you a note and let you know what a wonderful time we had staying at your beautiful house in Key West.  WOW!  The house was a joy to stay at, everyone loved it...especially the three bathrooms.  It was like we all had our own suite.  The deck, the grill, the CD player.  I could go on and on.  We loved it and will recommend it to our friends.  We had a great time and really enjoyed Key West!  Thanks for sharing your paradise with us."


February 20, 2005 from Steve-stayed in our Truman Annex Porter Lane 3 Bedroom House:

"Well, another month in paradise has come and gone and I'm back in the frigid North.  Had a great time and enjoyed the house very much.  The work you and Cindy have done on the place is really nice!  The new kitchen arrangement makes the home much more livable and even more comfortable than before.  Kudos to your design team!  I'd like to reserve the place again around the same time next year.  Thanks again for providing a great place to spend my winter vacation!  I'm looking forward to next year!"


December 29, 2004 from Pat-stayed in two of our Truman Annex Fleming St Houses:

"Just wanted to tell you what a wonderful time we had in Key West and our accommodations were part of the reason.  Your places are wonderful!  My husband, daughter and I stayed in 216 Fleming and the rest of the family stayed in 214.  Both places are just great!  They are ideally located and they are so "homey" feeling.  Couldn't have been better.  I will recommend you and your homes to anyone!"


May 2, 2004 from Annie-stayed in our Truman Annex Porter Lane 3 Bedroom House:

"Hi-We love the house-there's so much room we get lost!  The outside area is wonderful and the wireless DSL is great.  We're looking forward to a relaxing and warm month.  Thanks!"

March 22, 2004
from Mona-stayed in one of our Truman Annex Fleming Houses:

”Craig and Cindy...hello from the cold weather, again!!  We arrived home last week to three inches of snow!!!  Wanted to let you know we truly enjoyed staying at your place in Key West.  We had a great time and the home was beautiful.  Larry and I would like to reserve next February...looking forward to hearing from you!"

February 23, 2004 from Tanya-stayed in our Duval Square townhouse:

"Just wanted to say Thank You and to tell you how much we enjoyed our stay.  We are sorry to hear you no longer own this unit.  It was a pleasure to deal with you and Cindy in such a professional manner.  I will refer you to any Friends interested in any of your properties.  Thank You Again!!"


January 5, 2004 from Sharon-stayed in one of our Truman Annex properties:

”We enjoyed staying at Truman Annex.  The place was fabulous!  We really enjoyed the special music (you provide).  We looked all over Key West for the picture of Jimmy Buffett's house (hanging in the house) but couldn't find it.  Hope you had a wonderful holiday.  Again, we thoroughly enjoyed the home.  It was spacious and decorated beautifully.  We definitely will call you for our next rental.  Many Thanks!"


December 24, 2003 from Mary Lou-stayed in one of our Truman Annex properties:

"Craig and Cindy, Hope all is well.  I just wanted to tell you that we loved our 'home away from home on Porter Lane' in Key West back in November.  Thanks again and I hope your holidays are the best!"

December 15, 2003 from Mary-stayed in one of our Truman Annex properties:

"I just wanted to tell you that we enjoyed the condo so much.  We had everything we needed and more.  It was so clean and neat when we got there.  The cleaning lady did an excellent job.  If any of our friends or relatives decide to go to Key West (and I hope they do!), I would certainly recommend your properties to them.  And should we come back next year, we would like to stay there again.  Thanks for making our trip so enjoyable."


December 10, 2003 from George-stayed in our Duval Square Townhouse:

"Just a quick note of thanks...the condo was PERFECT!  We had most of the comforts of home and couldn't have been more pleased.  Next time we head for Key West, you can be certain we will be in touch."

October 28, 2002 from Kevin-stayed at our Hilton Head Oceanfront Beach Villa:

”Craig/Cindy, Just a short note to express our thanks for our recent visit to Palmetto Dunes Oceanfront property.  We especially appreciated the wine glasses, which our wine connoisseur loved.  The rooftop sundeck was terrific, the ocean seemed only 50 feet away, and the bedrooms were large and cozy.  We loved the high ceilings and you really do know how to renovate properties.  Everything was tasteful, clean and modern.  Thanks again."


October 15, 2002 from Barbara-stayed in our Duval Square Townhouse:

”We had a lovely time at your condo at Duval Square.  Everything was perfect.  We didn't look for anything we needed that we didn't find.  The furnishings were so right for the Key West atmosphere, the beds were comfortable, and the location couldn't have been better.  Thanks so much for offering such a great place to stay.  We will certainly recommend it, and should we ever plan a trip to a location where you have accommodations, we will be back in touch."


August 14, 2002 from Jeff-stayed in our Truman Annex properties:

”Thank you for sharing your beautiful townhouse in Key West.  This rates as the finest vacation we have ever had!  The kitchen is beautiful and I wish ours was that new!  Everything was in tip top order…everything was so smooth which made the vacation even more terrific!  We would love to return to your place next year.  Again thanks for everything.”


August 11, 2002 from Phyllis-stayed in our Truman Annex properties:

”I just wanted to write and thank you for helping us find such great accommodations in Key West.  The Truman Annex was the perfect place for all 3 generations of our family.  My mom was able to get around freely without anyone transporting her, the younger generation enjoyed “partying” on Duval until all hours without having to be concerned about choosing a designated driver, and my husband and I enjoyed the fun on Duval but appreciated getting away to some peace and quiet whenever we needed it.  And we all enjoyed the pool!  The next time we visit Key West we’ll definitely contact you to arrange for a place to stay.”


July 7, 2002 from Chris-stayed in our Hilton Head Ocean Front Beach Villa:

”I just wanted to let you know that we arrived back from your vacation house last night and I just wanted to say thank you from our whole family.  We all had a great time.  This was my wife and myself’s third time in Palmetto Dunes, but we have never been on the beach.  If you ever want to sell your Beach Villa, let us know, I think you will have 3 potential buyers.  Thanks again.”


July 1, 2002 from Steve and Marcha-stayed in our Duval Square Townhouse:

”Just a quick note of thanks for the way you do things with your Key West rentals.  We just spent a wonderful week at your new 1075 Duval Square condo, what a pleasure!  It’s in a great location, not too far from the action, like you say, but far enuff up Duval to be quiet at night…a truly great time was had by all.  You will be hearing from us again in the next year about rentals in Key West or Hilton Head.  Thanks again.”


July 1, 2002 from June-honeymooned in one of our Key West properties:

”Craig, thank you so much for a wonderful honeymoon.  We were so close to everything.  We took your suggestion and ate at Lattitudes after our wedding.  It was perfect.  We will DEFINITELY come back and rent more of your properties and bring all our friends.  We fell in love with Key West.  Thanks again.”


June 18, 2002 from Sharon & Charles-stayed in our Truman Annex properties:

”Returned home on Sunday after one of the nicest vacations that I can remember in a long time.  Your place was beautiful and we really were surprised that it was so well equipped.  There was not a thing missing that we could think of.  If you would like to steer other clients to me for a referral, I will sing nothing but high praise for the way things were handled and for the wonderful place in which we stayed.”

April 20, 2002 from Bill & Chris-stayed in our Truman Annex properties:

”Well, we are back in Farmington Hills, Michigan but our hearts remain in Key West.  Your property was fantastic.  What a nice layout and Craig you have done a great job on upkeep/repairs.  Once again your units remain the tops of the rental opportunities in the Truman Annex.  Your description of the view from the balcony as a peak-a-boo glimpse of the Gulf in my opinion does not do it justice.  We spent much time up there watching Cruise ships docking out on the Mole (e.g. Truman Docks).  We will definitely be back as soon as our schedules permit.  Thanks once again for your personal phone call Craig and your prompt replies to my email inquiries.  Looking forward to paradise once again.”

April 13, 2002 from Barry & Lisa-stayed in our Duval Square Townhouse:

”Lisa and I arrived back home last night and we just wanted to take a moment to thank both of you profusely for the accommodations at the Duval Square Townhouse.  We couldn’t have enjoyed ourselves any more if we tried.  The townhouse was everything you said and more!  You are a man of your word, Craig, and we find that to be a rare commodity these days.  It was quiet and relaxing at the townhouse, yet we were within walking distance of everything we wanted to see and do.  We can’t thank you both enough for providing us with a very memorable vacation in a casual, exotic locale.  We will definitely recommend you to friends and family.  As for us, next stop Hilton Head.  I’ll contact you when we decide to make our plans for the trip.”


December 3, 2001 from Lorraine and Steve-stayed in our Shipyard Condo (comment about “followed your advice” relates to our comprehensive check-in booklet which also lists our favorite places to eat and suggested things to do):
”Alas, it is time to leave Key West.  We love the funky Conch Republic and had a great time.  Your condo was very comfortable and it is such a great location.  Close, but not too close.  We loved being able to walk everywhere.  We followed your advice and got Cuban sandwiches at Jeanna’s, breakfasted at Blue Heaven, lunched and dinnered at Bagatelle’s.  We can also highly recommend Alice’s at LaTeDa and the Rooftop down near Mallory Square.  We would recommend your condo highly and plan to return.  Thanks again for everything.”

September 29, 2001 from Suzanne and Mark-stayed in our Porter Court townhouse right after the 9/11/01 tragedy:

”Well, after a shaky start at the airport on the 15th, we actually made it to your beautiful home at Porter Court.  The accommodations well exceeded our expectations!  I don’t think we could have found a better location, considering everything was within walking distance.  Although this was our first time renting with you, it certainly will not be our last.  When visiting Key West, we will never stay anywhere else!  Thanks again for everything.  It was a pleasure doing business with you.”


July 25, 2001 from Bruce and Michelle-stayed in our Porter Court townhouse:
”I just wanted to e-mail you about how we again enjoyed our stay at your condo, Porter Court 403.  This was our fourth visit to Key West and as always we enjoyed it very much.  We have stayed in your condo’s on the last three visits and each time were very pleased with our accommodations.  Our friends also stayed in your (Porter Court) unit #410, also having an excellent experience.  Thanks again for a wonderful experience and we will certainly make reservations again in the future.”

June 27, 2001 from Diane and Gordon-stayed in our Hilton Head Villa:

”Just back from Hilton Head – we had a great time and we loved your home – hope to return soon!!!  Thanks for sharing your home with us.”

June 26, 2001 & August 4, 2001 from Jack and Sally-stayed in our Porter Court townhouse:
Getting ready to leave for Key West (June 26th):  “Just wanted to comment on the booklet you sent with the keys.  We are very familiar with Key West, but for anyone who hasn’t been there before – what a great help!  We’ve rented at many different places before, but apparently not with anyone so organized, and it always helps to have all those phone numbers in case of emergency or problems, so thank you so much.”

After returning from Key West (August 4th):  “Just wanted to drop you a quick line to thank you for a wonderful vacation.  We really enjoyed our time at (Porter Court) 403 even though the weather was unsettled for a good part of our stay.  Thank you also for allowing us an extra day at the end due to the storm…we would enjoy renting from you again-possibly late October or early November.”


December 18, 2000 from Stephanie (Payette, ID)-stayed in our Shipyard Condo:

“This is a little overdue, however, I wanted to say thank you for the wonderful accommodations in Key West and your gracious kindness in answering all of our questions prior to our vacation.  We all had a wonderful time and would recommend it to all of our friends who have yet to experience the culture of that area!  One thing I will say is that we couldn’t have received better weather!!  Ahhhh!!  Once again thank you so much for replying to my e-mails and kind responses!  I’m absolutely sure we would NOT have found a better place to stay!”

December 15, 2000 from Ann (Chandler, AZ)-has stayed with us 3 years in a row in both our Porter Court Townhouse and Sunset Key Overlook Home-these comments are for Sunset Key:
”Sorry for the delay in following up with you regarding our fabulous vacation.  I arrived home to a surprise business trip to Detroit/Toronto.  Anyway, all I can say is wow, wow, wow!  What a marvelous home on a marvelous island!  There are not enough adjectives to thoroughly describe our vacation at your new home!  The interior design is beautiful while remaining cozy and comfortable.  The exterior surroundings are exquisite.  You two truly have a piece of paradise.  Thank you so much for allowing us the fantastic opportunity.  By the way, the mural turned out wonderful.  It took both of us a bit of time to realize were the ½ bath was located.  I think you’ll be pleased.”


You are currently viewing Craig & Cindy's Prior Guest Comment Page
Craig & Cindy also offers other Key West rentals & other important info.

Click Below to Return to the Following Craig & Cindy Key West Home Pages:
Introduction to all Craig & Cindy Vacation Rentals

Click Below to Other Important Information of Craig & Cindy Key West Rentals:
Craig & Cindy Key West Rental Rates
Current Rental Specials
Location Map for Craig & Cindy's Key West Rentals

Click here to e-mail us to request our free Key West brochure or to inquire on availability!

We truly love Key West and Hilton Head and believe our properties are the best accommodations for experiencing paradise.  We look forward to sharing them with you!

Craig & Cindy Tellerd
fax 440-899-1295
email (click here):

website (click here):  http:/